You can find me on Google Plus. The short link is http://gplus.to/mwlucas.
No real content there yet. No idea what if anything I will do with it. But I’ve put a blanket down on my little patch of park, at least.
FreeNAS 8.0 and SNMP
Today, I learned that FreeNAS 8.0’s SNMP isn’t quite all one could hope for. The good news is, the bugs will be fixed in 8.0.1. I’m posting this in the hope of saving others the annoyances I had.
To SNMP query a FreeNAS 8.0 host, you must force the client to use SNMPv2.
# snmpwalk -c public -v 2c freenashost
Additionally, you can’t change the community name (at least on the amd64 version). You must use public.
This is fixed in 8.0.1. Still, it makes me glad I hacked a firewall into my FreeNAS box.
Full up on OpenSSH reviewers
I now have all the reviewers I can manage, and am not looking for more. I’d make an exception if you’re, say, an OpenSSH or PuTTY developer, but other than I’m not accepting any more. I’d like to thank everyone who has volunteered to review this book.
add PF to FreeNAS 8
I won’t put any system on the Internet without some sort of packet filter or firewall. Especially not a file server containing important data. While I have a FreeNAS 8 box, it doesn’t come with a firewall. FreeBSD includes three firewalls, IPFW, IPF, and PF. Any one of these would do, but I’m most comfortable with PF, so I decided to add PF to my FreeNAS install.
This will not add a firewall to the GUI. You must manage your rules remotely. The FreeNAS backup will not back up your rules. The good news is, once your firewall works the rules don’t change very frequently.
First, get the appropriate kernel module. You’ll need the ISO for the version of FreeBSD that your FreeNAS is based on. FreeNAS 8.0 is based on FreeBSD 8.2. I’m running the amd64 version of FreeNAS, so I need the amd64 version of FreeBSD 8.2. The version must match as exactly as possible: your 8-stable amd64 desktop might work, but it might make your FreeNAS box crash and die.
Mount the ISO.
$ mdconfig -a -t vnode -f $HOME/FreeBSD-8.2-RELEASE-amd64-livefs.iso
md0
$ mount -t cd9660 /dev/md0 /mnt
I previously installed FreeNAS on a 2GB USB stick. For this process, I shut down my FreeNAS box and mounted the USB drive on my FreeBSD machine. You could work directly on the FreeNAS image and re-install it on the USB drive, or even work directly on the live FreeNAS box. I’m assuming you’re working on a USB stick.
$ mount /dev/da0s1 /mnt
Start by getting the PF kernel module from the ISO onto your USB drive.
$ cp /media/boot/kernel/pf.ko /mnt/boot/kernel/
Now for the tricky bit. FreeNAS is based on the FreeBSD diskless system. (Obligatory plug: I did half a chapter on diskless operation in Absolute FreeBSD.) It uses the /conf directory to create a series of memory-based filesystem overlays, creating a MFS /tmp, /etc, and so on. This means that any changes you make to, say, /etc/pf.conf will not survive a reboot. You must edit the original versions of these files, in /conf/base/etc.
In /conf/base/etc/rc.conf, add
pf_enable=YES
Put your pf.conf in the same directory. Configuring PF is left as an exercise for the reader.
Any firewall changes made to a running system must appear in /etc/pf.conf and in /conf/base/etc/pf.conf. I suggest changing the base file, and copying changes to /etc.
FreeNAS 8 on Intel SS4200-E
The boss snagged an Intel SS4200 NAS as part of the corporate “redundant array of inexpensive crap” strategy. Basically, it’s a small, headless amd64 machine with 512MB RAM, four SATA ports, plus eSATA and USB. Add four 1TB hard drives, and you have a decent small storage device. I decided to try FreeNAS 8, so I could get ZFS, NFS, and iSCSI.
FreeNAS 8 installs on a USB drive. I got a 2GB USB from Micro Center checkout counter, and escaped the store without purchasing anything else.
Start by getting the FreeNAS full install, aka FreeNAS-8.0-RELEASE-i386.Full_Install.xz. Verify the checksum, then decompress the image.
$ unxz FreeNAS-8.0-RELEASE-i386.Full_Install.xz
Use file(1) to check it.
$ file FreeNAS-8.0-RELEASE-i386.Full_Install
FreeNAS-8.0-RELEASE-i386.Full_Install: x86 boot sector; partition 1: ID=0xa5, active, starthead 1, startsector 63, 953505 sectors; partition 2: ID=0xa5, starthead 1, startsector 953631, 953505 sectors; partition 3: ID=0xa5, starthead 0, startsector 1907136, 3024 sectors; partition 4: ID=0xa5, starthead 0, startsector 1910160, 41328 sectors, code offset 0x31
My USB drive is available as /dev/da0. Copy the image to the drive.
$ dd if=FreeNAS-8.0-RELEASE-i386.Full_Install of=/dev/da0 bs=5k
While that’s running, console into the SS4200. The serial console connector seems to be a standard DB9 connector, so you can just pull one off of an old motherboard. If your null-modem cable doesn’t seem to work, try reversing the connector on the motherboard. I connected with 115200 8n1, no flow control.
Go into the BIOS. Select Advanced, then go down to USB. Set your USB emulation type to “hard disk.” Then go into the boot order and have it boot from hard drives. Go to the Hard Disk Drives menu beneath that and make your USB device first on the list.
If you don’t have the console connection, boot the SS4200 from USB by holding down the reset button (tiny black dot by the rear USB port) for about 2 seconds while powering on. The light will turn amber to show that it’s booting from USB. This will work for home use, although you’ll need to do this every time you reboot the NAS. You’re really better off setting the BIOS properly.
Once dd finishes, plug the USB drive into the SS4200 and power up. The default FreeNAS IP is 192.168.1.250, but if you have a DHCP server it will grab a proper local IP. Check your DHCP server logs for a host called “freeNAS,” and point your browser at that address.
Once I was in, I easily added data storage, creating two 931-GB ZFS mirrors.
I successfully created group for my new account. I couldn’t create a user, but it’s a known problem with workarounds.
Lastly I enabled the serial console by going to System->Settings. Oddly, there’s no setting to set the console speed. You can change the SS4200 serial port to 9600 in the BIOS, but that seems less than optimal. It’s a petty issue, however, as I can reconfigure my serial connection trivially.
I found a FreeNAS 7/SS4200 tutorial buried inside the FreeNAS forums. While all the FreeNAS stuff has changed, it was quite helpful for setting up the SS4200 hardware and BIOS.
Overall, FreeNAS 8 looks pretty. The real test will start when I put a bunch of diskless NFS and iSCSI clients on it and watch for stuff to break. It must have better iSCSI than the Iomega NAS’s I’ve been arguing with…
OpenSSH community reviewers wanted
UPDATE: I have all the reviewers I can handle.
I have about half of the OpenSSH book written. I can start getting feedback on the manuscript. If you’re interested in providing feedback, first read the review process article on my web site.
If you’re still interested after reading that article, send me an email with the subject “OpenSSH review” and tell me that a) you won’t share the review manuscript, and b) why you’d be a good reviewer. I can only manage so many reviewers, so I try to pick readers of every experience level. My email address is m w lucas at black helicopters dot org.
And before you ask: four chapters of the OpenBSD book are finished. Not enough to solicit reviewers. It is proceeding apace, though. I usually work on multiple projects simultaneously, so this is not unusual.
How Community Tech Review Works
I’ve received quite a few questions about how I do community-based tech reviews on forthcoming books, as well as offers for one or both of the projects I have underway. I’ve put up a public Web page about the process I follow. I expect to request community reviewers for one book later this week.
Realistically, my brain is limited. I can only manage about 20 prepub reviewers for a given project. I choose the best people from the pool of volunteers.
I hope that all of them will return useful comments. I expect that about 10 of them will return nothing. Another 5 will drop out halfway through.
So, if you volunteer and I don’t pick you, you can feel superior in knowing that you would have been one of the 25% to stay all the way through, except that I wasn’t smart enough to know that beforehand.
desktop OpenBSD pf.conf
I have an OpenBSD 4.9/i386 desktop sitting naked on the Internet, and found people poking at my TCP ports. While PF is enabled by default, it’s configured to permit everything except remote X11. I need a policy that will block incoming traffic from everywhere except a few key IP addresses, while allowing me to make any outbound connections I desire.
mgmt="{192.0.2.0/24, 192.168.8.0/24}"
set skip on lo
block
pass proto icmp
pass from $mgmt to self
pass from self to any
block in on ! lo0 proto tcp to port 6000:6010
Disabling ICMP globally is a bad idea. Lots of stuff will break. I could specify permitted ICMP types, but that would be a lot of work and probably break my connectivity to random in a really obscure but educational manner.
I retained the X11 block, even for those known-good addresses, because if I’m trying to open an X11 connection to my home desktop without forwarding it over SSH, I am clearly solving the wrong problem.
If I permit password-based SSH connections from “known good” hosts, such as my house and the office, then if one of those machines is penetrated, the intruder will be able to get into my machine. I protect my desktop by requiring SSH public key auth, even from trusted IP addresses. An intruder could be savvy enough to hijack my agent forwarding, but in that case it’s someone specifically targeting me.
The current PF syntax is as close to painless as a firewall can be.
SSHv1 and PuTTY
One of the advantages of writing books is that you must double-check everything you thought you knew about a topic. PuTTY is probably the most widely deployed SSH client in the world. I’ve used it for years. It’s good software. (I also use the OpenSSH client, of course.)
To my surprise, PuTTY accepts both version 1 and 2 of the SSH protocol. It prefers version 2, but will accept 1.
Version 1 of the SSH protocol has irremediable problems. If a client accepts SSHv1, an attacker can intercept a new SSH connection and force it to downgrade to SSHv1. He can inject arbitrary commands into the SSHv1 stream. These problems have been known since 1998. Increases in computing power have made executing these attacks much simpler.
Worst of all, Ettercap can decode SSHv1 in real time. If Wireshark cannot decode SSH now, I suspect it will soon.
In my mind, this puts SSHv1 into the same category as Telnet and unencrypted read-write SNMP; stuff that Just Should Not Be On My Network.
I absolutely understand why PuTTY supports SSHv1 by default. The generous people who spend their free time writing PuTTY aren’t interested in supporting folks who can’t be bothered to read the instructions. I might make the same decision in their place.
And yes, host key verification helps eliminate MITM attacks. But do your users really verify host keys? Really and truly? The PuTTY FAQ lists “How do I turn off the annoying host key verification prompt?” as a question. As a sysadmin, I translate this as “yours users don’t verify host keys, and mine don’t either.”
There’s no reason for anyone who actually reads this blog to routinely permit SSHv1, and the appearance of security is worse than no security. I encourage you to disable SSHv1 by default in your and your users’ clients. Users can override the default on a host-by-host basis, but at least they must make the conscious effort. They’ll probably ask you for help. This will help you find lingering SSHv1 servers. If you have some embedded device that only speaks SSHv1, well, you have a job to do. That job should include replacing that device or yelling at the vendor.
How do you disable SSHv1 in PuTTY? Open PuTTY. On the left side, go to Connection->SSH. Select “2 only.” On the left side, select Session (at the top). Highlight “Default Settings.” Click Save. PuTTY saves its configuration in the registry, so you can export this setting and apply it to your client PCs through whatever method you use.
The most annoying part of this change is that PuTTY’s default settings do not propagate to all of the previously saved sessions. You must update them by hand or recreate them. I suspect that you could use some sort of script to update your saved sessions from your registry, but I can’t find such a thing. (This would be a great add-on tool for some Windows programmer looking for a way to contribute to the community.)
I will continue to highly recommend PuTTY to my Windows-based friends, with a note on how to disable SSHv1. As a lowly user who has no right to complain and who doesn’t have to listen to users whinge, though, I’d like to say to the PuTTY folks: researchers broke SSHv1 thirteen years ago. It’s time to stop accepting it by default.
Summer 2011 nonfiction project: OpenSSH
I have a problem with Absolute OpenBSD, 2nd edition. It’s too big. The outline is 26 chapters. This brings the book close to 300,000 words, well over a thousand pages. I don’t want to write books that I don’t like. I don’t like huge books that I cannot comfortably read in the bathtub.
One component of OpenBSD is OpenSSH. People have written books about OpenSSH, but they contain more information than most people need. (Not all, but most.) I write for the most common user, which means that those books are perhaps 2x-3x the size of what I would write. And OpenSSH is widely used outside OpenBSD: I could argue that it’s their most widely deployed component. Lots of people who will never use OpenBSD need a swift sharp smack with the OpenSSH clue-by-four.
AO2e book needs some OpenSSH stuff in it, of course. But I have about 30,000 words of OpenSSH. For comparison, the smallest nonfiction book I’ve written is about 60,000 words. It’s too small for a traditional publisher.
So I’m removing the intermediate-level OpenSSH material from AO2e, and doing a small independent book tentatively titled “OpenSSH: Your Next Steps.” It will cover the OpenSSH server, and the OpenSSH and PuTTY clients.
Many people believe they know how to use SSH: they download PuTTY, enter a hostname, username, and password, and “poof!” — they’re secure. It’s not that simple. If you search for documentation and articles about using OpenSSH, you’ll find years and years of accumulated cruft. Many of the most visible articles and posts are obsolete. A single source of up-to-date information at an inexpensive price would find readers, and would let me satisfy my self-publishing curiosity. I’ve contemplated independent publishing for some time now, and this looks like a realistic opportunity.
I’ll have to pay for copyediting, design, and so on. And I’ll have to manage the whole project. Worst case, I lose a lot of time and money, but develop a new appreciation for my publisher. (I still cannot see leaving them for major books like AO2e, however; it’s just too much work.)
I believe that there’s a market for inexpensive, small, single-topic books, as Cisco Routers for the Desperate is one of my best-selling books on Kindle. Not bad for a two-year-old book. I could also make the case that if you want a book called “Cisco Routers for the Desperate,” you want it NOW. (The publisher could probably double the price without impacting Kindle sales, but that would be gauche.)
I will do a community-based tech review. I’ll announce here when I’m looking for reviewers.
Finally: at Austin Hook’s request, I’ll also do a print-on-demand version. (I’m not terribly interested in distribution of physical copies of such a short book, but the expense and annoyance of setting up POD isn’t that great, so why not?) Austin handles the sale and distribution of the various OpenBSD merchandise, so I have confidence he can manage this.
As an independent, I cannot do pre-orders for books that don’t yet exist. There are Web sites that manage this for authors, but I really don’t want to bother. But Austin does that all the time, and he’s a trusted community figure. He will be the official source for pre-orders. While POD books need to be paid for in advance, the money doesn’t come to me until the books are ready to print and ship. This will get some extra cash in the hands of the folks who develop OpenSSH, which is a good thing.
No, I don’t have numbers or prices yet. I’m taking a course on this stuff, as well as POD, though, so I’m not even trying to figure that out yet. I can assure you that the paper version will be more expensive than the electronic version, however.
Will this succeed? There’s only one way to find out.
UPDATE: I’m not shelving AO2e for the summer. I normally work on multiple projects simultaneously. When I’m sick of one, I work on the other.